Good Different

Starred review from February 20, 2023
In Kuyatt’s heartfelt debut, free verse poems explore middle school changes via the first-person viewpoint of an autistic 12-year-old. Selah Godfrey has always liked rules-oriented Pebblecreek Academy, where she knows exactly “what I’m/ supposed to do.” But when she enters seventh grade, everything’s different. Amid the crowded hallways, loud cafeteria, and itchy new uniforms, Selah’s rules for “Being a ‘Normal’ Person” include resisting the urge to talk about dragons, remaining on her “Best Behavior,” and otherwise masking until she can calm herself in the bathroom. When a classmate braids her hair without asking, and Selah’s reaction causes a bloody nose, Selah is regarded as a social pariah and threatened with expulsion. Isolated from her peers, she takes the advice of her beloved, similarly wired grandfather and starts to write in a notebook, further finding her voice through a kind English teacher’s poetry assignment. Kuyatt, who is autistic, uses candid lines to present Selah’s story, conveying her mother’s well-intentioned denial of Selah’s needs, and Selah’s own experiences, self-knowledge, and eventual self-advocacy. Selah is white. An author’s note and resources conclude. Ages 8–12. Agent: Lauren Spieller, TriadaUS.